When Only Murders in the Building first hit Hulu in 2021, it felt like a cosy mystery with a modern twist, blending classic whodunit storytelling with the chaos of true-crime podcasts.
Four seasons later, it has only gotten more ambitious. With a new season on the horizon, fans are eager to know what’s next for Mabel, Charles, and Oliver—and whether they’re running out of luck.
Is Season 5 the Last Season of Only Murders in the Building?
Speculation has been circling like a nosy neighbour in the Arconia lobby: Will Season 5 be the final instalment?
The show’s co-creator, John Hoffman, has played it both ways.
Some sources suggest the show was originally envisioned to span five or six seasons, meaning this could be the beginning of the end.
Others point to Hoffman’s remarks about wanting to continue for as long as there’s a story to tell.
The actors’ availability, particularly Steve Martin’s interest in maintaining the show’s momentum, will likely be a deciding factor.
What Can We Expect from Only Murders in the Building Season 5?
While speaking to Variety, showrunner John Hoffman revealed that Season 5 will explore a mix of classic and modern New York, focusing on themes of tradition and change.
The death of Lester, the Arconia’s long-time doorman, serves as the entry point to this season’s mystery, tying into the show’s larger narrative about history and evolution.
Hoffman also teased that the season will be deeply tied to Sofia Caccimelio’s story, hinting at unexpected connections between her missing husband and the Arconia itself.
Beyond the mystery, the trio will once again find themselves pulled into the chaos of their personal lives.
With Only Murders shifting its lens toward New York’s past and present, expect Season 5 to explore themes of power, legacy, and the city’s hidden corners that still hold dark secrets.
Given the show’s trajectory, this season will likely push Charles, Oliver, and Mabel to their limits, both as detectives and as individuals.
The balance of comedy and drama remains key, but this season could lean into a grittier noir feel—if the fan theories are to be believed.
Who’s Returning for Season 5?
The central trio—Selena Gomez, Steve Martin, and Martin Short—will, of course, return.
Meryl Streep’s Loretta Durkin, who stole hearts last season, may or may not be back, depending on how her storyline unfolds.
Téa Leoni’s Sofia will take on a larger role, while recurring characters like Howard (Michael Cyril Creighton), Detective Donna (Da’Vine Joy Randolph), and Uma (Jackie Hoffman) are also expected to reappear.
What Did the Trio Reveal About Season 5?
@onlymurdersonhulu We had our lawyers call business affairs. Turned the 4 into a 5. #OnlyMurdersInTheBuilding ♬ original sound – Only Murders In the Building
In a video posted to social media, Steve Martin, Martin Short, and Selena Gomez confirmed that Season 5 is in the works, though they admitted they had yet to shoot anything.
Their playful back-and-forth hinted that fans might have to wait until 2025 for new episodes, keeping in line with the show’s previous release patterns.
When Will Only Murders in the Building Season 5 Be Released?
While Hulu hasn’t confirmed an official release date, production is expected to begin in March 2025.
If the show follows its usual release schedule, Season 5 could arrive in late summer or early autumn.
The timeline remains uncertain, but one thing’s clear: the wait will be filled with fan theories, Reddit deep dives, and plenty of debate over who the real culprit might be.
As always, Only Murders in the Building thrives on its ability to surprise, so whatever theories are out there, the showrunners are probably a few steps ahead.
Whether this is the final act or just another twist in the story, Season 5 is shaping up to be a major chapter in the Arconia’s ever-growing history of crime, chaos, and questionable sleuthing.
